Best Credit Cards

New Card Approval Restrictions by Bank Issuer

I’ve been meaning to put a post on new card approval restrictions for some time, and use it as a point of reference going forward. It’s no secret that during the last few years there have been many negative changes implemented by banks. The goal is very simple: to stop people from applying for cards with the sole purpose of collecting sign-up bonuses.

So, I wanted to compile what we know at this point so you don’t waste your credit inquiries needlessly. Keep in mind, things in this hobby can change overnight, so some of the info may no longer apply by the time the post goes live.

Without further ado:

Chase

The bank that started it all. They have what is called a 5/24 rule. What it means is if you got  5 or more new cards from any bank (not just Chase) in the last 24 months, you will be automatically denied. Usually, business cards don’t go on your personal credit report, but that’s not always the case. You can sometimes bypass the 5/24 rule if you are pre-approved in branch.

Here is an interesting comment from my reader Brad: “I was just able to get around 5/24 for the 80k Chase Ink Business Preferred  offer when I used a $500 bonus coupon ($30 on ebay) to open a new biz checking. The business banker who did it for me pushed a paper app through a different group. They looked at how much I used my current Chase cards and I spread minor spend around on them to keep them active.” YMMV

It’s important to remember that not all Chase cards are subject to 5/24 restriction. Few notable exceptions: IHG, British Airways and Hyatt co-branded cards. Those are excluded from 5/24 rule (for now). As of late, there is mixed data on business version of Marriott card.

Keep in mind that Chase-issued cards have a rule that states that you only qualify for the sign-up bonus if you haven’t received it in the last 24 months. Having a card still open won’t hurt your chances of getting the bonus, but you will have to cancel it before applying again. Reader Steve has reminded me that Chase Sapphire Preferred and Chase Sapphire Reserve have  a separate rule in place. You won’t be eligible for the sign-up bonus if you’ve received it on either product within 24 months. You can not hold those cards simultaneously.

American Express

As of now, this bank doesn’t have any approval restrictions aside from one bonus/per lifetime rule. As long as your credit score is high, you’ll have a good shot at approval. In the past, you could only have 4 American Express credit cards at one time, not including charge cards. However, latest reports indicate that the rule is not written in stone, as some have been able to get their 5th Amex credit card. YMMV

Citi

Citi doesn’t have a rule similar to Chase 5/24.  You will qualify to receive the bonus as long as you haven’t opened or closed a card within the same “family” in the last 24 months. What the term means: Citi issues different versions of AAdvantage and Thank You-earning products, and they belong to two separate “families.”  Keep in mind, business versions don’t count.

For example, Citi Thank You Premier and Citi Prestige belong to the same “family.” If you got Citi Prestige in September of 2016 and closed it in September of 2017, you will not be eligible for sign-up bonus on Citi Thank You Premier till October of 2019. Reportedly, converting the card instead of canceling may circumvent this rule, but the data is mixed at this point.

Barclay

All the recent data suggests that Barclay has now implemented a 6/24 rule, but ONLY for their Barclaycard Arrival Plus World Elite MasterCard. It works the same way as Chase 5/24 rule. As of now, none of the other cards are affected, but that could change at some point in the future.

Reportedly, you can receive the sign-up bonus multiple times without any restrictions (aside from 6/24 rule), but there are no guarantees. Barclay is usually pretty tough on approvals, especially for those who like to switch cards on a regular basis.

You can follow comments and see data points in this DoC post.

Bank of America

BoA has a 2/3/4 rule. They’ll only approve you for two cards per rolling 2 months, three cards per rolling 12 months, and four cards per rolling 24 months. Keep in mind, only BoA cards count, not those with other issuers. That’s why it’s the least restrictive rule so far. Reportedly, you can receive the sign-up bonus multiple times without any additional restrictions.

You can follow comments and see data points in this DoC post.

Capital One

Capital One doesn’t have any restrictions on card approvals or new bonus qualifications. The current card has to be closed, though. Be aware, Capital One pulls all three credit agencies and they are VERY sensitive to new inquiries. Neither my husband or I can get a card with that bank. And we’ve tried.

Bottom line

There are other banks, of course, but the ones I’ve listed usually have the most lucrative sign-up offers. Miles and points game is getting tougher, no question about it. That said, opportunities are still there as long as you keep your expectations reasonable and understand these new card approval restrictions.

The new trend is getting targeted offers from banks that don’t contain any restrictive language. When the economy tanks (and it will), I suspect a lot of these rules will be reversed. Until then, we’ll adapt and make the most of what we have.

If you’ve found this content beneficial, please look at Support the Site page for ways you can help keep the blog running. Also, subscribe to receive free updates through email and recommend the site to your family and friends. You can follow us on Twitter and Pinterest, like us on Facebook and download  free e-book.

Author: Leana

Leana is the owner and founder of Miles For Family. She enjoys beach vacations and visiting her family in Europe. Originally from Belarus, Leana resides in central Florida with her husband and two children.

It's only fair to share...Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterPin on PinterestShare on LinkedIn

2 thoughts on “New Card Approval Restrictions by Bank Issuer

  1. Thanks for putting this together – very helpful. Also, with Chase there are now restrictions which prevent you from getting more than one Sapphire card within a 24-month period since they are in the same family. I have been timing my recent SW Rapid Rewards Plus card for the minimum spend to be met in January, 2018, then hoping to get the SW Rapid Rewards Premier early next year when I fall to 4/24 – then qualify for the Companion Pass with the bonus and a little more spend. However, I now have concerns about these 2 cards being in the same family and not receiving the bonus for both (although I see nothing on the application pages). I read one travel blog comment where the bonus was denied for second card since they were in the same family; others (before Oct. 2017) have been successful in getting both. The last thing I want is to be approved for the card, meet the spend and not get the bonus – I don’t need another credit card! I have thought maybe about sending a secure message to Chase asking if the credit card is approved and min. spend met if I would receive the bonus – but then again, maybe I should not draw their attention to it. What do you think?

    • @Steve Thanks for the reminder on CSP and CSR having a separate “family” rule. Believe it or not, I forgot all about it. At times, it’s hard to keep everything straight in this hobby!
      On SW cards, you could try messaging Chase, but they will probably claim it’s considered the same product. Very often the reps don’t really know all the technicalities themselves. If you do get approved, I think you will have an excellent chance at getting the bonus. I think it’s worth a shot. Lately, Chase started denying those who they don’t deem to be eligible for bonus. So, I think that’s what will happen if you don’t qualify. If you happen to have a business of some sort, you could apply for business version, which would be a safer bet.

Leave a Reply