During my recent cruise on Mariner of the Seas, I had a chance to check out cruise line’s private CocoCay island in the Bahamas or as Royal Caribbean refers to it, Perfect Day at CocoCay. It rhymes!
Did it live up to the hype? Read the post to find out. These private islands, purchased by cruise lines, are certainly not everyone’s cup of tea. Some feel they are too artificial, too crowded etc. Personally, I love them. You don’t have to fight off vendors at the pier, haggle with taxi drivers or look over your shoulder at the public beach, hoping no one is hiding in the bushes waiting to rob you.
Obviously, I’m making generalizations here, and not all major Caribbean ports are that way. But the unfortunate reality is that most islands suffer from high unemployment which puts many citizens in a desperate state. As a result, some aggressively hawk wares, others resort to crime.
This in turn can put cruise passengers in the constant state of unease, unable to relax and enjoy themselves. Enter private islands owned by cruise lines, where you can forget all of your worries, if only for a day.
Overall impressions of CocoCay
Let me first say that I had a fabulous time and would not hesitate to book a cruise that includes a stop at CocoCay. That being said, I’m not a huge fan of its “waterpark” theme and wish Royal Caribbean execs exercised some restraint in this regard. Leaving the ship and walking towards the island, I found the whole thing jarring and tacky.
IMO this type of attraction ruins the beautiful landscape and simply doesn’t belong on a low-key Bahamian island. To me, the biggest appeal of these type of cruise stops is the unspoiled nature of it all.
I once spotted a bird nest on a trail in Half Moon Cay, a private island owned by Carnival (also used by Holland America). Not happening here. That island is an absolute gem, and I highly recommend it. Half Moon Cay is one of my favorite spots in the world, and I hope Carnival doesn’t follow Royal Caribbean’s lead. I’m not holding my breath.
Building this waterpark was a bad call IMO, but I can tell you for sure that I’m in the minority. Many reviewers seem to love the changes. Plus, let’s face it, most kids will have a blast in the waterpark. But be prepared to shell out some cash because it costs extra. It’s my understating that price varies depending on your sailing date, but on our cruise it was $40 per person if we pre-booked ahead.
When I saw that, I said Nope. I’ve already paid enough for the cruise as is. Plus, there is a decent waterslide on the ship itself. However, my sister-in-law really wanted to take the kids, so she paid for them. She spoils them rotten.
Guess what? Both of my rascals were too scared to go on the waterslide (supposedly, the tallest in the United States), though they enjoyed the wave pool in the waterpark. So, my SIL was quite disappointed and didn’t feel the whole experience was worth $120. YMMV, but make sure your kids will not chicken out like mine did.
I feel like there are just too many variables if you want to book ahead. Your kids may get sick, the weather may be bad etc. I personally feel that waterpark is in the “skip” category. I do think it was a brilliant decision (profit-wise) to put that waterslide front and center when you exit the ship.
Fortunately, most parts of the island don’t require a separate fee. There is a huge resort pool:
There are also multiple water play areas for little kids that don’t cost extra:
That’s why I don’t think you should feel compelled to pay for the waterpark. Your kids may be perfectly happy with included amenities.
A huge positive to me is the fact that you don’t have to use tenders to access the island. Royal Caribbean has recently invested in a dedicated pier, so you can walk off the ship with no wait whatsoever.
This is huge because when an island requires tender boats, the stop reportedly ends up being cancelled about 30% of the time due to rough waves. No such issue here, so you are very likely to visit CocoCay unless there is a hurricane or an unusually bad weather.
Carnival is actually planning to add a dedicated pier to Half Moon Cay, but it won’t happen until 2021 at the earliest. In this case, I’m happy Carnival is copying Royal Caribbean. But for now, CocoCay is in a unique position that sets it apart from other private islands owned by mainstream cruise lines.
There is a tram that transports cruise passengers from pier to the island, so those with mobility issues should be able to get around without a problem.
Crowds at the beach
Let’s face it, for most folks the biggest appeal of this island stop is the beach. It certainly was for me. The good news is that there is enough room for people to spread out, even when two RCCL cruise ships are visiting at the same time.
That said, it depends on the size of the ship. If you are on Oasis-class (over 5,000 passengers) and there is another ship in town, it could get ugly. We were on Mariner which fits 3,300 people, and the ship next to us was the same size.
My husband and I went to the island at around 9 AM, and there were plenty of chairs. I was pleasantly surprised by the fact that umbrellas don’t incur an extra charge. Most private islands only provide regular chairs.
So thumbs up to Royal Caribbean for not trying to make an extra buck here. My husband had cancer spots cut off on his face, so shade is absolutely essential. I certainly would have paid for an umbrella.
The beach was nice, but there was a lot of seaweed when you swam further out. Snorkeling is mediocre, though I did see some colorful fish. My favorite thing was swimming out to the floating platform and just relaxing on it with my feet in the water. The water was cold, but I decided to be a brave gal and get in anyway.
There are several options for those who want a more exclusive experience. The beach cabanas start at $400 for the day (gulp!), but they sure look sweet.
A cheaper alternative are beach beds, which start at $200.
In my younger days I would never consider paying for something like that. However, knowing how much my husband hates crowds, I may splurge on a beach bed next time we are there. If you rarely come to the Caribbean, consider treating yourself. Book ahead! That said, using complimentary chairs is perfectly fine, too.
There are several beach sections and by noon, they were about 75% full. One relatively empty section was located by the construction area. This is where the overwater bungalows are going to be located soon. See Nancy’s post for more details. Paying $1k is a bit rich for my blood, but to each his own.
There was some noise from hammers, but nothing terrible. I only discovered this beach during a walk, after my husband and I were already settled on the opposite side. I didn’t want to disturb him, but I switched later after he went back to the ship. This section is located a bit further from the food pavilion.
<
p style=”text-align: center;”>Much better!
There was a low tide in the afternoon, but the views were still gorgeous. Also, this is where the floating bar is located, and I couldn’t resist splurging on a mixed drink ($14).
In fact, that was our total spending on this island, so I can’t complain. The cruise line even provides food in a pavilion, so we didn’t have to go back to the ship to have lunch. You can grab a glass of iced water or lemonade any time you wish. Alcohol costs extra. There were plenty of clean restrooms all over the island.
One thing I wish I did was take a hot air ballon ride, so I could enjoy a panoramic view of the surrounding area. Maybe next time.
Final thoughts
I had a wonderful time on this island and view it as a highlight of the cruise. It helped that the weather was perfect on the day we visited. There was a nice breeze, so my husband ended up taking a nap in the lounger.
Even though I’m not a big fan of the waterpark addition, once on the beach, I didn’t have to look at it. It wasn’t an exclusive private-island experience in the true sense of the word since I had to share it with 6,000 fellow companions. Still, I feel like Royal Caribbean has put a lot of thought into managing the crowds. And finally, having a complimentary umbrella was a nice touch. All in all, thumbs up.
Readers, please share your impressions of CocoCay!
CLICK HERE TO VIEW VARIOUS CREDIT CARDS AND AVAILABLE SIGN-UP BONUSES
Author: Leana
Leana is the founder of Miles For Family. She enjoys beach vacations and visiting her family in Europe. Originally from Belarus, Leana resides in central Florida with her husband and two children.
Anonymous says
How come nobody talked about the amazing night with the water show And music. I do agree with the water slide prices when the ones on the ship were good. The free food was very comparable to the ships cafe. Oh yeah there were little carts to take you back n forth. We went back before dinner n rode slides 4 times each. Piggy swim was cool and quite educational. My family was not disappointed at all
Leana says
I don’t remember any mention of the water show on the island, though maybe we left before they had it? Oh, and thanks for mentioning one important detail. There is a tram that transports folks in CocoCay. Very important for those with mobility issues.
Terry says
“…look over your shoulder at the public beach, hoping no one is hiding in the bushes waiting to rob you” “Obviously, I’m making generalizations here, and not all major Caribbean ports are that way. But the unfortunate reality is that most islands suffer from high unemployment which puts many citizens in a desperate state. As a result, some aggressively hawk wares, others resort to crime. This in turn can put cruise passengers in the constant state of unease, unable to relax and enjoy themselves. Enter private islands owned by cruise lines, where you can forget all of your worries, if only for a day.”
Ouch. High employment leads to desperate state leads to hawking wares or resorting to crime. Travel is supposed to open your eyes. Hope you’re pumping some of your money into these islands to help improve the economic situation.
Leana says
@Terry Thanks for your comment! I completely understand where you are coming from. Oof, that’s a tough topic that probably deserves a separate post, but here are my two cents on the matter.
First, let me assure you that I didn’t mean to come off as flippant. Poverty is no laughing matter, and deserves compassion. But I also don’t like to mince words.
Do cruisers like me contribute to a local economy? To an extent, yes. Remember, we also stopped in Nassau and each passenger (7 people in my family) paid port charges. I also paid for my kids and in-laws to go on an excursion which benefited a local tour operator. In addition, Royal Caribbean apparently hires local people to work on their private island. So indirectly, we indeed improved the economy in the Bahamas in our own small way. Will it solve the poverty issue? Of course not!
I will also be 100% honest with you and admit that when I was first planning this trip, the welfare of Bahamas residents was not my main concern. I simply wanted for my family to relax and have a good time. My husband works in a very stressful environment, so the idea of kicking back on a nice island without worrying about potential crime was extremely appealing. It doesn’t mean that I’m paranoid and think that everybody in the Caribbean is out to get me.
Before we had kids, we used to rent a scooter or hire a local taxi driver, and explore the islands. It was a lot of fun, and nobody robbed us. In fact, once we asked a guy to keep an eye on the scooter and went to enjoy the beach. He agreed, and even refused a tip when we returned. Most Caribbean folks we have encountered were incredibly friendly and hospitable. Bad “apples” can be found in any country, but poverty exacerbates the problem of crime. That’s a fact.
After having kids, I am much more cautious than I used to be. I will no longer drive to a deserted beach in a poor country. So, stopping on a private island owned by a cruise line instantly eliminated most of my concerns. Of course, it doesn’t mean that we don’t explore local places as a family. See this post on our trip to Jamaica https://milesforfamily.com/2017/03/31/venturing-beyond-inclusive-resort-history-art-horticulture-jamaica/
Nancy says
Thanks for the review, Leana. I’m torn about the water park. For my cruise in 2021, the current price is $99 per person for the water park. It was $79 a few months ago. I hope it goes down before my cruise. I’m fairly certain my daughter will be too chicken for the slides, and I definitely don’t want to spend that much for her to enjoy the wave pool. My boys, on the other hand, will be 13 and 16, and I’ll never hear the end of it if they can’t go on those slides.
Leana says
@Nancy Hmm, that’s a tough one! I certainly wouldn’t fault you if you decided to splurge on the boys. That said, $99 per person, yikes. I personally wouldn’t pay it, plus, I’ve heard that the tall slide has long waits (45 minutes or more). How many times are they going to go, realistically speaking? Once, twice? That’s a steep price to pay. And if the weather doesn’t cooperate, it may be a total bust. Plus, Oasis has a really cool slide on the ship.
Maybe hire them to do some chores and let them decide if they want to spend the earnings on the waterpark? 🙂
Kacie says
Do we need to bring towels with us onto the island?
Leana says
@Kacie Forgot to mention the towel situation! So, you will need to check out towels on the ship with your key card. They set up a stand near the exit, and that’s where you return them as well. I wish they let you do it on the island, but it’s not a big deal either way. Make sure to pack a beach bag in your suitcase for storing all the junk.
jessica s says
I was just there last week and I was able to checkout towels on the island. I did have to return them on the ship though.
Leana says
@Jessica That’s good to know! We were told to check out the towels before leaving the ship, but maybe they have changed this policy.
Kacie says
I’m really excited for the island! I don’t plan to disembark at Nassau. I see some itineraries now offer two stops at the island. Jealous! I wish I booked that one.